The mayoral bid of NYC Comptroller Brad Lander is expected to set off a chain reaction of political maneuvering among other progressive Democrats. Lander’s challenge to Mayor Adams in the 2025 Democratic primary will leave the comptroller’s race open, creating opportunities for other candidates. This unexpected turn of events has sparked excitement among progressive Dems who see Adams as beatable in a primary.
According to Democratic consultant Jon Paul Lupo, this situation is rare in New York City politics. The last time a sitting citywide official challenged a mayor was in 2009. These challenges tend to create competition and openings for seats, making it an exciting time for aspiring politicians.
One of the consequences of Lander’s mayoral bid is the potential candidacy of Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine for comptroller. This move would leave Levine’s post vacant, and term-limited Manhattan Councilman Keith Powers would run for borough president. It’s a strategic game of musical chairs, with politicians positioning themselves for the most favorable opportunities.
Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso is also considering a run for city comptroller. This decision is a significant one for Reynoso as he contemplates becoming the first Latino to win a citywide elected office. However, there is a source familiar with his thinking who suggests that he is unsure and may choose to play it safe and run for a second term as borough president. In either case, fellow Democrat and term-limited Brooklyn Councilman Justin Brannan is eyeing a comptroller run as well.
If Reynoso decides to run for comptroller, Brannan would shift gears and run for borough president. However, if Reynoso opts out, Brannan would pursue the comptroller position instead. There is also Councilman Chi Ossé from Brooklyn, who is considering a run for borough president if Reynoso decides to run for comptroller.
On the other hand, Assemblywoman Jenifer Rajkumar, a moderate Queens Democrat and Adams ally, has already announced her intention to run for city comptroller. Her candidacy adds a different dynamic to the race, as she aligns herself with Adams and represents a more moderate approach within the Democratic Party.
Overall, the upcoming political musical chairs in New York City reflect the changing dynamics within the Democratic Party. Progressive Democrats see an opportunity to challenge the more moderate incumbents and push for a more progressive agenda. The comptroller’s race, along with the potential shifts in borough president positions, will be closely watched as the political landscape continues to evolve.
