Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

California officials highlight modest gains in student test scores under Newsom amid continued concerns

California education officials announced modest statewide improvements on the 2025–26 student assessments, calling the results the third consecutive year of progress under Governor Gavin Newsom. The announcement highlighted rising shares of students meeting higher performance levels in English language arts, math and science as well as declines in chronic absenteeism and suspensions. Critics responded that, despite those gains, overall proficiency rates remain low and long-standing achievement gaps persist.

Key takeaways

  • State officials said 2025–26 CASPP results marked a third consecutive year of statewide improvement in ELA, math and science, and reported declines in chronic absenteeism and suspensions.
  • Officials presented combined Developing/Proficient/Advanced percentages of 71% (ELA), 61.8% (math) and 86.5% (science); critics emphasize Proficient/Advanced rates of 49.3% (ELA) and 38.4% (math).
  • Analysts note the narrower proficiency metrics are near or below pre-pandemic 2018–19 levels and that long-standing achievement gaps remain.
  • Debate centers on how the state frames progress, the role of increased spending, and whether governance changes will boost accountability and outcomes.

What the state reported

At an event in Downey, officials said the 2025–26 California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CASPP) results showed increases in the percentage of students scoring at Proficient or Advanced across English language arts (ELA), mathematics and science, marking the third year of statewide improvement. The state release cited growth in combined categories — Developing, Proficient and Advanced — to describe the share of students demonstrating grade-level performance “with increasing accuracy and complexity.” According to that presentation, the combined percentages were 71% in ELA, 61.8% in math and 86.5% in science, and science performance rose above pre-pandemic levels.

Officials also highlighted non-test indicators. The state said chronic absenteeism continued to decline across all grade levels and that suspension rates were at their lowest point since 2019, outside the pandemic years.

Numbers and comparisons raised by critics

Commentators and education analysts pointed to other published CASPP figures to temper the state’s framing. One analysis highlighted that 49.3% of students in grades 3–8 and grade 11 met grade-level standards — defined as scoring Proficient or Advanced — in ELA for 2025–26, an increase of 0.5 percentage points from the prior year. For math, the share meeting grade-level standards (Proficient or Advanced) was reported at 38.4%, up 1.2 percentage points year over year. Those figures mean a majority of students did not reach the Proficient/Advanced threshold: 50.7% in ELA and 61.6% in math according to that reporting.

Analysts also noted comparisons with pre-pandemic results. One critic cited CASPP percentages from 2018–19 showing 51.7% proficiency in ELA and 39.7% in math, observing that the 2025–26 figures remain below those pre-pandemic levels in those two subjects.

Points of dispute in how progress is presented

The state’s messaging combined the Developing category with Proficient and Advanced when describing the share of students demonstrating grade-level performance “with increasing accuracy and complexity.” Some outside voices said that approach can make year-to-year improvement look larger because the Developing category does not meet grade-level standards. Critics argued the state’s use of combined categories and selective district-level highlights risks obscuring underlying low proficiency rates; state officials framed the same data as evidence that investments such as expanded transitional kindergarten, literacy and math supports, community schools and universal school meals are contributing to incremental gains.

Spending, governance and accountability debate

Critics pointed to the state’s rising education spending under Governor Newsom and his predecessor while saying outcomes have not risen commensurately. Reporting cited per-pupil funding increases during Newsom’s term and questioned whether additional dollars have translated into stronger academic results.

Separately, observers have identified governance and accountability as persistent challenges for California K–12 education. One analysis described changes approved this year that alter the role of the State Superintendent of Public Instruction—moving toward an appointed Department of Education leadership model with a governor-appointed commissioner and governor-decided state board membership—intended, proponents say, to centralize accountability. That same source noted several state-level bills aimed at strengthening governance had mixed legislative outcomes.

Why this matters to Californians

Statewide test results inform numerous policy choices that affect funding priorities, interventions for low-performing districts and classroom practices. The differing interpretations of the 2025–26 CASPP data matter for decisions about where to direct new investments and whether structural changes to governance are required to improve outcomes. The gap between combined-category measures and the narrower Proficient/Advanced metric is central to debates over how quickly students are recovering from pandemic-era disruptions and whether progress is sufficient.

Unresolved questions and what to watch

  1. Whether the incremental year-to-year gains continue and accelerate: the state reported small percentage-point increases in 2025–26, but analysts note the pace would need to quicken to close the gap with pre-pandemic proficiency and raise proficiency for the majority of students.
  2. How state budget pressures will affect K–12 funding commitments: reporting has noted recent multibillion-dollar budget gaps in California and the use of deferred school aid as one fiscal tool, which could complicate sustaining higher per-pupil spending.
  3. Whether governance changes yield clearer accountability and better student outcomes: proponents of an appointed commissioner model argue it centralizes responsibility; critics say structural change alone may not translate into improved classroom learning.

Timeline (selected items cited in state and commentary)

  • 2018–19: Pre-pandemic CASPP proficiency cited as 51.7% ELA and 39.7% math (used for comparison by critics).
  • 2018–2026: Per-pupil spending increased under two governors, according to commentators who noted spending rose sharply during Newsom’s tenure.
  • 2025–26: State officials announced the CASPP results showing third consecutive year of statewide improvements and cited combined Developing/Proficient/Advanced shares of 71% ELA, 61.8% math and 86.5% science; the state also reported declines in chronic absenteeism and suspension rates.

Bottom line

California’s official release frames the 2025–26 CASPP results as evidence of continuing progress under Governor Newsom, citing gains across subjects and improvements in absenteeism and school discipline. Independent commentators and education analysts welcome any upward movement but underscore that less than half of students met Proficient or Advanced standards in ELA and fewer than four in ten did so in math, and that those narrower proficiency measures remain close to or below pre-pandemic levels. The data and competing interpretations leave open central policy questions about how to accelerate improvement and ensure taxpayer dollars translate into stronger academic outcomes for all students.

Popular Articles