The Giants’ 2024 NFL Draft class is full of surprises, as general manager Joe Schoen deviated from his previous strategies. The team did not select a quarterback, did not address the offensive or defensive lines, and did not make any trades during the draft. Despite these departures, the Giants managed to improve their team with a mix of offensive and defensive players.
The standout player of the draft class is wide receiver Malik Nabers, who was selected in the first round. The Giants initially wanted quarterback Drake Maye but were unable to secure the trade. However, Nabers was highly regarded by some teams as the top receiver and second overall player. With an impressive reputation and a versatile playing style, Nabers is expected to become the Giants’ number one target and a major playmaker for the team.
The second-round pick, safety Tyler Nubin, brings a ballhawking element to the Giants’ defense. Known for his intelligence, toughness, and dependability, Nubin is projected to be a starter and will provide support in run defense. While his coverage speed may be a concern, it could be attributed to playing through a torn meniscus that required surgery.
In the third round, the Giants selected cornerback Dru Phillips, who adds depth to their secondary. While the team needed an outside cornerback, Phillips is more suited for the slot position. It remains to be seen how the Giants will utilize him, but his physicality and hitting ability make him a valuable asset.
The fourth-round pick, tight end Theo Johnson, is seen as a preparation for Darren Waller’s potential retirement. Johnson’s pass-catching abilities need improvement, especially in terms of being a deep threat. Additionally, his blocking skills could use some work. This pick may have been forced or motivated by a perceived need on the team.
Running back Tyrone Tracy from Purdue was chosen in the fifth round. Tracy initially played as a receiver but switched positions and excelled as a running back. He also proved himself as a valuable special teams player with his kickoff return abilities. While some may feel this pick was made too early for a returner, the Giants lacked a threat in that area for a long time.
The final pick of the draft class is linebacker Darius Muasau from UCLA. With an impressive tackling record and a history of durability, Muasau adds depth to the linebacker position and could push for playing time alongside Bobby Okereke.
Overall, the Giants’ 2024 NFL Draft class receives a grade of B-. While there were some surprising choices and departures from previous strategies, the team managed to select players who could make an impact on both sides of the ball. With standout player Malik Nabers leading the way, the Giants are hoping to see improvements in their offense and defense in the upcoming season.
