Gas Stove Ban Partially Rolled Back in Victoria, Australia
In a recent development, the Victorian Labor government has made changes to its policy aimed at achieving net zero emissions by 2045. While the ban on gas installations in new properties will remain, Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan has assured residents that they can continue to cook on existing gas stovetops. However, if they need to replace their stovetop, they will be able to do so. This move is aimed at supporting households and businesses that can transition to all-electric options while maintaining a gas supply for those who still rely on it.
The ban on gas connections in new properties in Victoria has been a topic of discussion. The government’s 2023 gas substitution roadmap had previously mentioned the possibility of electrifying both new and existing residential and commercial buildings. The Victorian government believes that modern induction cooking is efficient, convenient, and safe, and considers it a healthier choice compared to traditional gas stovetops. Citing recent studies that have shown potential health risks associated with gas cooking, the government is encouraging a shift towards electric alternatives.
The response to the government’s decision has been mixed. The Institute of Public Affairs, a free market think tank, criticized the Victorian government for limiting new gas connections, stating that it forces Victorians to choose between heating and eating. On the other hand, the Victorian Greens claimed that gas cooktops contribute to climate change and cause complex health issues, including childhood asthma. They accused the premier of denying climate science and undermining the government’s efforts to address the climate crisis. The Liberal opposition also criticized the Labor government, accusing them of making desperate policy changes to secure votes.
However, a study published in the Lancet Medical Journal in May found no significant increase in the risk of wheezing or asthma from gas stove use compared to electricity. The authors of the study confirmed that previous studies may have exaggerated the risk of asthma from gas use due to a lack of adjustment for confounding factors. While there was a slight increase in the risk of acute lower respiratory infections and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease associated with gas use, it was not statistically significant. Interestingly, the study also noted a significant decrease in the risk of bronchitis.
In conclusion, the Victorian Labor government has partially rolled back its policy on gas stoves in order to support households and businesses in transitioning to all-electric options. While the ban on gas installations in new properties will remain, existing gas stovetops can still be used, and replacements will be allowed when necessary. The decision has received criticism from the Institute of Public Affairs and the Liberal opposition, while the Victorian Greens have praised it for addressing climate change and health issues. A recent study has found no significant increase in the risk of asthma from gas stove use. Overall, the debate surrounding gas stoves in Victoria highlights the importance of considering both environmental and health factors when making policy decisions.
