Teenager on Field Trip to Detroit Court Ends up in Jail Clothes and Handcuffs: Judge Claims “Scared Straight” Approach

Teenager on Field Trip to Detroit Court Ends Up in Jail Clothes and Handcuffs

Introduction:
A field trip to a Detroit court took an unexpected turn for a teenager who ended up in jail clothes and handcuffs. The incident occurred when Judge Kenneth King, who works at 36th District Court, took issue with the girl’s attitude during the visit organized by The Greening of Detroit, a nonprofit environmental group.

Judge King’s “Scared Straight” Approach:
Judge King defended his actions, stating that he wanted to make the experience look and feel real for the teenager, even though there was no real chance of her going to jail. He likened his approach to the “Scared Straight” documentary about teen offenders in New Jersey. By having the girl change into jail clothes and wear handcuffs, he aimed to convey the seriousness of courtroom conduct.

The Incident:
During the field trip, Judge King noticed the girl falling asleep in his courtroom. According to video footage, he warned her that if she fell asleep again, he would have her placed in the back. Unsatisfied with her attitude and disposition, Judge King decided to take more drastic measures to get through to her.

The Greening of Detroit’s Response:
The Greening of Detroit, the organization that organized the field trip, released a statement expressing their concern for the traumatized young lady. While acknowledging the judge’s intention to teach respect, they deemed his methods unacceptable. They suggested that if he believed the students were disrespectful, he should have simply asked them to leave the courtroom.

Judge Sabree’s Statement:
Judge Aliyah Sabree, holding the No. 2 leadership post at the court, issued a statement distancing the court from Judge King’s conduct. She emphasized that his actions did not reflect the standards upheld at 36th District Court. Judge Sabree expressed her commitment to addressing the matter diligently.

Criticism of Judge King’s Approach:
Larry Dubin, a professor at the University of Detroit Mercy law school, criticized Judge King’s approach, stating that there were many other ways to help the young girl learn. Dubin implied that the judge’s actions were excessive and unnecessary.

Judge King’s Attempt to Make Amends:
Following the incident, Judge King spoke to the girl’s parents and offered to be a mentor. This gesture suggests that he acknowledges the potential harm caused by his actions and wants to make amends.

Conclusion:
The incident involving the teenager on the field trip to the Detroit court has sparked controversy and raised questions about Judge King’s approach. While he defended his actions as a way to convey the seriousness of courtroom conduct, critics argued that there were more appropriate ways to teach the lesson. The Greening of Detroit expressed concern for the traumatized young lady, and Judge Sabree emphasized that Judge King’s conduct did not align with the court’s standards. Larry Dubin, a law professor, suggested that there were alternative methods to help the teenager learn. Despite the backlash, Judge King attempted to make amends by offering to be a mentor to the girl.