Reports of antisemitism perpetrated by masked protesters have been a cause for concern in New York and nationwide. The Post draws attention to the parallels between the current situation and Nazi Germany, particularly regarding the use of masks during protests. However, it is crucial to acknowledge a significant distinction between the two eras. While in Nazi Germany, Jewish communities were victimized by the police, today they are protected by law enforcement agencies.
The escalation of antiÂsemitism in Nazi Germany involved the full participation of the police, who ruthlessly suppressed dissent, enforced discriminatory laws, and facilitated the deportation of Jews to ghettos and concentration camps. In stark contrast, the police in the United States uphold their duty to safeguard Jewish citizens and communities. It is important to recognize that the police force is not homogeneous, and there may be individuals who act improperly. However, on a daily basis, police officers protect the diverse communities that make up the American mosaic, including the Jewish community.
Despite this protection, there have been instances of homes owned by Jewish people being defaced, which is deeply saddening. Such acts can be seen as pure vandalism rather than a form of protest. Comparisons can be drawn to acts committed in Nazi Germany and by the KKK within the United States. It is essential that all those who engage in acts of hate and antisemitism are arrested and held accountable for their actions.
Mayor Adams attending pro-Israel rallies is a positive step, but more needs to be done. He should collaborate with his police commissioner to develop a strategy and establish a citywide task force to address any mob terrorizing any group of people. As a former captain with the NYPD, Mayor Adams should be aware that the police have the power to arrest these individuals. However, it may be unrealistic to expect assistance from President Biden and the federal government in this matter.
Furthermore, there is a call for Mayor Adams and Governor Hochul to collectively advocate for the reinstatement of New York’s 200-year old mask law, which was repealed during the COVID-19 pandemic. The urgency for this reinstatement is emphasized, as the situation may escalate to a New York City Kristallnacht if no action is taken.
In addition to banning mask-wearing at protests, it is also important to examine hate-speech laws, such as those in the United Kingdom. Hate speech often precedes hate crimes and goes beyond civil opposition and free speech protections. Platforms like social media have already taken steps to remove hate speech, and similar measures should be implemented in the public arena as well. Laws protecting all races, ethnicities, and individuals from hateful speech can help combat antisemitism and ensure a safer and more inclusive society.
Following Germany’s lead, the United States should consider outlawing antisemitism and symbols of hate. By taking decisive action, there will be no ambiguity about who should be arrested for perpetuating hate crimes. It is crucial for individuals to voice their thoughts on this matter and engage in constructive dialogue to address and combat antisemitism effectively.
